36  E. Main Street
Washingtonville, NY 10992

 (845) 496-3631

About Us


Tuthill Agency, Ltd., is not employed by any one company.

As an insurance consumer, you can benefit from utilizing our services, because we represent represent over twenty insurance companies. This gives our agency the ability to choose between the companies we represent in order to tailor an insurance program to your individual needs.

Our friendly, professional and knowledgeable staff is always ready to assist you with your insurance needs.

Your Team is Here To Serve You

Scott C. Greene, President, CIC – President, Business/Life/Health/Disability/Personal Insurance

  • 5th Generation family owner of Tuthill Agency
  • Born in Blooming Grove, NY


  • Graduate of Ithaca College, B.A. 1980
  • Graduate of Washingtonville High School 1975
  • Licensed Insurance Broker/Agent, Since 1980
  • Certified Insurance Counselor for 25 years

Community Activities:

  • Former President Blooming Grove/Washingtonville Rotary
  • Vice President of Blooming Grove/Washingtonville Chamber of Commerce
  • Former Board Member of Arden Hill Foundation
  • Member and Volunteer Mid Hudson Adirondack Mountain Club
  • Member of Orange County Chamber of Commerce
  • Member of the Moffat Library Committee

Professional Associations:

  • Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers Association
  • Professional Insurance Agents
  • Society of Certified Insurance Counselors


Janet T. Myers, CSR – Personal Insurance

  • Born in Campbell Hall, NY


  • Insurance Brokers License received 1979
  • Insurance Brokers Course at OCCC 1978/1979
  • Graduated Washingtonville High School


  • Various positions held in the insurance industry over 25 years
  • Former part-owner of Thompson Insurance Agency, Washingtonville, NY
  • Tuthill Agency since 1986

John Jaros, CSR – Personal Insurance


  • Graduate Marlboro High School 1980
  • Graduate Mount Saint Mary College 1986


  • Member St. Francis Roman Catholic Church, Newburgh, NY

Lydia Negron, CIC – Office Manager, Business/Personal Insurance


  • Graduate Theodore Roosevelt High School
  • Attended Mercy College for Business Administration
  • Certified Insurance Counselor for over 20 years


  • Treasurer Orange County YWCA
  • Former Treasurer Unitarian Universalist Congregation, Rock Tavern, NY
  • Former Board Member Blooming Grove Day Care Center


new-york-central travelers sterling progressive
hartford foremost ohio gmac
grange hagerty hanover selective
General Casualty farmers first-rehab
Tuthill Insurance Agency
36 East Main Street
Washingtonville, NY 10992


Phone: 845-496-3631
Fax: 845-496-3622

Click here to email us


Driving Directions