36  E. Main Street
Washingtonville, NY 10992

 (845) 496-3631

Customer Service and Claims

These insurance claims phone numbers are for your use if you need immediate assistance from your insurance provider.

Insurance COMPANIES / PHONE #’s

Click on any logo to be taken to that specific website (will open in a new window)

new-york-central
New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company
1-888-234-6926

 

travelers
Travelers
1-800-238-6225

 

sterling
Sterling Insurance Company
1-800-462-4661

 

progressive
Progressive Casualty Insurance Company
1-800-247-4499

 

foremost
Foremost Insurance Group
1-800-527-3907

 

gmac
1-800-462-2123

 

hagerty
Hagerty Insurance
1-800-922-4050
hanover
Hanover Insurance Group
1-800-628-0250
hartford
The Hartford Insurance Group
1-800-327-3636
Insurance claims Web site – auto >
Insurance claims Web site – home >

 

blue-ridge
Blue Ridge (a division of General Casualty)
1-800-668-3494

 

farmers
Farmers Insurance Group
1-800-435-7764

 

grange
National Grange Insurance
1-877-425-2467

 

first-rehab
First Rehabilitation Life Insurance
Company of America
(516) 829-8213

 

-595-859-LM_OhioCas-RGB.png-
Ohio Casualty Group
1-800-435-5543

 

selective
Selective Insurance Group
1-866-455-9969

new-york-central travelers sterling progressive
hartford foremost ohio gmac
grange hagerty hanover selective
General Casualty farmers first-rehab
Tuthill Insurance Agency
36 East Main Street
Washingtonville, NY 10992

 


Phone: 845-496-3631
Fax: 845-496-3622

Click here to email us

 


Driving Directions
Affiliations