36  E. Main Street
Washingtonville, NY 10992

 (845) 496-3631

Auto Insurance


No matter what your ride, we got you covered

When it comes to selecting the right automobile insurance policy, at The Tuthill Agency, you are always working with an experienced, knowledgeable, friendly employee.

We recommend all available auto discounts to you so that you can get the best price we offer while providing adequate insurance coverage for your needs and financial protection.

We represent six reputable automobile insurance companies who each offer many programs designed to meet the needs of any driver – regardless of driving record.

  • The Travelers Group
  • New York Central Mutual
  • Progressive
  • GMAC
  • Farmers Insurance Group
  • Sterling Insurance Company

Payment schedules for automobile insurance coverage are also very flexible. We offer low down payment options, electronic funds transfers, monthly billing, credit card payments and predetermined billing dates. Significant discounts are available if you pay in full!

new-york-central travelers sterling progressive
hartford foremost ohio gmac
grange hagerty hanover selective
General Casualty farmers first-rehab
Tuthill Insurance Agency
36 East Main Street
Washingtonville, NY 10992


Phone: 845-496-3631
Fax: 845-496-3622

Click here to email us


Driving Directions